Difference between revisions of "Feminist historical narrative"

From Wiki 4 Men
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 9: Line 9:
 
== Oppression ==
 
== Oppression ==
   
  +
Feminists argue that women have historically been systemically oppressed by men. This is at the centre of much of the outrage that feminists exhibit.
The narrative asserts that women have historically been systemically oppressed by men. Feminists tend to disagree on how long this supposedly went on for. Some say it lasted for a few thousand years while other argue it has existed as long as humans have existed. The narrative goes on to claim that women were freed by [[feminist]]s during the 20th century although they also often claim that women still need to be freed from the [[Patriarchy]]. The prevalence of women in the public sphere throughout history clearly shows falsity of this claim.
 
  +
 
Feminists tend to disagree on how long this apparent oppression went on for. Some say it lasted for a few thousand years while other argue it has existed as long as humans have existed. The narrative goes on to claim that women were freed by [[feminist]]s during the 20th century although they also often claim that women still need to be freed from the [[Patriarchy]]. The prevalence of women in the public sphere throughout history clearly shows falsity of this claim.
   
 
History is replete with examples of women that were allowed to adopt male roles when they wanted to. It may be that these women were perceived by contemporary men as being particularly competent.
 
History is replete with examples of women that were allowed to adopt male roles when they wanted to. It may be that these women were perceived by contemporary men as being particularly competent.
   
Some feminists have even gone on to claim that women were slaves throughout history.
+
Some feminists have even gone on to claim that women were slaves throughout history. Claims that women could not own property or did not have any rights are more common. These claims, to the extent that they were ever true, can also be examples of the [[Victorian fallacy]].
   
 
[[File:2024-03-12-120125_646x215_scrot.png|400px]]
 
[[File:2024-03-12-120125_646x215_scrot.png|400px]]
   
Here Tigerfly Free were slaves until two generations ago.<ref>https://twitter.com/tigerfly22/status/1767294668801519766</ref><ref>https://archive.is/wip/V96ub</ref>
+
Here Tigerfly Free claims that women were slaves until two generations ago.<ref>https://twitter.com/tigerfly22/status/1767294668801519766</ref><ref>https://archive.is/wip/V96ub</ref>
   
 
Examples include:
 
Examples include:

Revision as of 09:23, 12 March 2024

An example of the feminist historical narrative from a Christian song sheet.

The feminist historical narrative is an historical narrative widely believed by feminists and others. The feminist historical narrative is so pervasive that even many non-feminists accept it. It is largely built of lies, half-truths and oversimplifications. The feminist historical narrative covers many areas.

Ancient Matriarchy

The ancient matriarchy is a discredited view that ancient human cultures were matriarchal.[1] Some feminists claim that these ancient matriarchal cultures were taken over or defeated by aggressive patriarchal cultures and that evidence of the past matriarchy was systematically hidden by The Patriarchy.[2][3]

Oppression

Feminists argue that women have historically been systemically oppressed by men. This is at the centre of much of the outrage that feminists exhibit.

Feminists tend to disagree on how long this apparent oppression went on for. Some say it lasted for a few thousand years while other argue it has existed as long as humans have existed. The narrative goes on to claim that women were freed by feminists during the 20th century although they also often claim that women still need to be freed from the Patriarchy. The prevalence of women in the public sphere throughout history clearly shows falsity of this claim.

History is replete with examples of women that were allowed to adopt male roles when they wanted to. It may be that these women were perceived by contemporary men as being particularly competent.

Some feminists have even gone on to claim that women were slaves throughout history. Claims that women could not own property or did not have any rights are more common. These claims, to the extent that they were ever true, can also be examples of the Victorian fallacy.

2024-03-12-120125 646x215 scrot.png

Here Tigerfly Free claims that women were slaves until two generations ago.[4][5]

Examples include:

Misogyny

Medieval Europe regarded women as morally superior men. This carries over to the modern day.

Patriarchy

In the West children inherit their father's name because the society was historically patrilineal not patriarchal.

The feminist claim that Patriarchy hurts men too is an oxymoron. Any Patriarchy that did not benefit men would be dysfunctional. This claim is just a response to MRAs and others successfully raising men's issues.

Sex

Feminists assert that women were only allowed to enjoy sex relatively recently. A review of of history around the world demonstrates that this is false.

Suffrage

In general nations that became independent during the 20th or 21st centuries granted universal suffrage to men and women at the same time. In nations that became independent before the 20th century men typically led women by a few years or decades in obtaining suffrage. Even a few decades should be seen as a short period of time given that human political thought has been developing for at least 5000 years.

Wealth and Power

Historically wealthy and powerful women have been common.

Anne Lister

Work

See Also

External Links

Further Reading